PhD candidate in Anthropology and History at the University of Michigan
In the aftermath of the 1948 War, church voluntary organizations in the UK and the US held mass clothing drives for Palestinian refugees. Though there was doubtlessly a practical need for shirts, shoes, and blankets among an abruptly dispossessed population, the momentum by which cloth was provisioned over other forms of relief raises several questions. This paper examines the rationale, logistics, and local reception of the clothing drives, asking: How were Palestinian refugees clothed, and what constituted an adequately clothed refugee?
Drawing on archival documents, photographs, magazines, and memoirs, my analysis takes up a multivocal approach.I begin by exploring the perspectives of missionaries-turned-aid workers, who sorted, bundled, and distributed the second-hand clothes that arrived in the camps. I suggest that they understood the task of clothing the Palestinian refugee body not only as a practical responsibility, but as a moral project, as an opportunity to forge rationed individuals and ideal gift recipients.
Equally, I weigh Palestinian responses to clothing aid. Far from passively accepting their rations, I show how most refugees undertook “rituals of possession” to personalize the garments they received.They washed, dyed, cut, patched, and rebuttoned. They emptied the clothes of their previous owners and made them anew, reenchanting them with their own desires and meanings. And they did not waste a weave. They employed the items that were beyond salvage as material for patching, quilting, and stuffing. They turned the ubiquitous flour sack into tents, curtains, bedding, pajamas, and underwear. For Palestinian refugees, making do meant finding ways to live with a prescribed set of things. I position their practices of repair and transformation as political acts of world-building, of “making livable lives” in conditions of dire material lack.
Through the lens of cloth, I survey the material environments of the refugee camp, center the everyday lives of Palestinians, and foreground their bodily experiences of dispossession. These experiences—of warmth and cold, comfort and pain, pride and indignity—did not leave paper trails for us to follow. Instead, they offer us a history “beyond words,” glimpses into the unspoken deliberations of survival, the visceral entanglements of self and other, and the changing dynamics of gender and family. Attending to them, I argue, allows us to nuance humanitarian categories of need, transcend the volubility of national narratives, and trace the echoes of the past in the present.
Dima Saad is a PhD candidate in Anthropology and History at the University of Michigan. Her research examines Palestinian history through the lens of clothing and presents an ethnography of traditional embroidery work today.